DEED 3D is the largest platinum partner of  ” Stratasys ”  in Asia, with more than 17 years of leading 3D printing technology and services.

Crafting Brilliance: An In-Depth Analysis of Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM) vs Multi-Jet Fusion (MJF)

Introduction

In today’s rapidly advancing technological landscape, 3D printing has emerged as a revolutionary manufacturing process that has captured the imagination of industries and individuals alike. Also known as additive manufacturing, 3D printing enables the creation of three-dimensional objects from digital designs, layer by layer.

 
This cutting-edge technology has opened up endless possibilities for designers, engineers, and artists to bring their concepts to life with unparalleled precision and efficiency. Within the realm of 3D printing, there are various techniques available.
 
Two prominent methods that have gained significant attention are Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM) and Multi-Jet Fusion (MJF). Both FDM and MJF offer unique advantages and cater to different needs in the world of additive manufacturing.
 
It is crucial for professionals and enthusiasts alike to understand the fundamental differences between these technologies before embarking on any project. By doing so, they can make informed decisions regarding which method best suits their requirements.

A Brave New World: An Overview of 3D Printing Technology

At its core, 3D printing involves taking a digital design or model and converting it into a tangible physical object through an additive process. Unlike traditional subtractive manufacturing methods that involve cutting or carving away material from a solid block until the desired shape is achieved, 3D printing builds objects layer by layer using only the required amount of material.
 
This transformative technology encompasses several different processes such as stereolithography (SLA), selective laser sintering (SLS), among others. However, Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM) and Multi-Jet Fusion (MJF) stand out as two widely adopted techniques due to their versatility and compatibility with various applications.

Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM): Bridging Imagination and Reality

Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM), also commonly referred to as Fused Filament Fabrication (FFF), is an additive manufacturing process that has gained immense popularity, particularly within the consumer market. FDM printers work by extruding a thermoplastic filament through a heated nozzle onto a build platform, creating layer upon layer until the desired object takes shape.
 
One of the key advantages of FDM technology is its accessibility and cost-effectiveness. With affordable printers readily available in the market, hobbyists, educational institutions, and small businesses can easily embrace 3D printing.
 
Furthermore, the range of compatible materials for FDM printers is extensive, including commonly used filaments such as ABS (Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene) Nylon12CF(carbon-filled), Ultem1010( high performance) and many more. This versatility allows users to select materials based on their specific requirements in terms of strength, durability, flexibility, or aesthetic appeal.

Multi-Jet Fusion (MJF): Precision Redefined

Multi-Jet Fusion (MJF) represents another breakthrough in 3D printing technology that prioritizes speed and precision without compromising on quality. Developed by HP Inc., MJF utilizes a fine powder bed composed of Nylon-based materials instead of thermoplastic filaments like FDM. The unique aspect of MJF lies in its utilization of multiple jets that apply both a fusing agent and an inkjet binding agent simultaneously to the powder bed.
 
The fusing agent selectively heats up specific areas within each layer while the inkjet binding agent helps define finer details and edges with accuracy previously unattainable by other methods. This simultaneous process enables faster print speeds compared to traditional techniques while maintaining superior surface finish and resolution.

Understanding Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM)

Explanation of FDM Process

The Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM) process is a widely used 3D printing technology that involves the layer-by-layer deposition of thermoplastic filaments to create three-dimensional objects. One of the key aspects of FDM is its simplicity and user-friendly operation.
 
The process begins with a digital model, which is sliced into numerous thin layers using specialized software. These layers serve as the basis for creating a toolpath that guides the movements of the printer’s extruder.

Introduction to Thermoplastic Filaments Used in FDM Printers

Thermoplastic filaments are at the core of FDM technology, providing a wide range of material options for printing objects. The most commonly used filaments include  Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene (ABS).
 
ABS offers excellent strength, durability, and heat resistance, making it suitable for functional parts and prototypes. 

Detailed Description of How Filament is Melted and Extruded Layer by Layer

Once the filament material has been selected according to specific requirements, it is loaded into the printer’s extruder system. Within this system, there are typically hotend components responsible for heating the filament until it reaches its melting point.
 
After reaching this temperature, an extrusion mechanism forces the molten filament through a fine nozzle onto the build platform or previously printed layers. As each layer solidifies almost instantly upon extrusion, the build platform moves down or the extruder moves up incrementally to create the next layer.
 
This meticulous process is repeated until the entire object is printed. The precision and control of the filament deposition allow for intricate details and complex geometries to be replicated faithfully in each layer, resulting in a final product that accurately reflects the digital model.

Advantages of FDM Technology

FDM technology offers several advantages that make it a popular choice among hobbyists, small businesses, and even larger enterprises: 
1. Cost-effectiveness and Accessibility for Hobbyists and Small Businesses: FDM printers are relatively affordable compared to other 3D printing technologies, making them accessible to individuals and small businesses with limited budgets. Additionally, since FDM printers use thermoplastic filaments instead of proprietary resins or powders, material costs are generally lower.
 
2. Wide Range of Compatible Materials: FDM technology allows for the use of various thermoplastic filaments, giving users flexibility in selecting materials based on specific functional requirements or aesthetic preferences. From standard ABS to flexible TPU (Thermoplastic Polyurethane) or engineering-grade nylon-based filaments like PA6 (Polyamide 6), there is a filament available for virtually any application.
 
3. Ability to Create Large-Scale Objects with Relatively Simple Machinery: Unlike some other 3D printing technologies that require complex setups or expensive equipment for large-scale prints, FDM offers a straightforward approach. By using a robust frame structure and sturdy mechanics, FDM printers have demonstrated their ability to produce life-size prototypes, architectural models, and even furniture pieces without compromising on print quality or structural integrity

Exploring Multi-Jet Fusion (MJF)

An Intricate Dance of Powder and Jets

Multi-Jet Fusion (MJF) is an advanced 3D printing technology that has gained significant attention for its ability to produce parts with superior surface finish and accuracy. The MJF process involves the use of powdered materials, typically nylon-based, which are spread in a thin layer onto the build platform.
 
Unlike Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM) where solid filaments are used, MJF printers utilize a liquid fusing agent that is selectively applied layer by layer using multiple jets. The powdered material acts as both a support structure during the printing process and as the base material for constructing the object.
 
The fusing agent is deposited precisely where it is needed to bind the powder particles together, forming solid cross-sections of the desired shape. This sequential application of powder and fusing agent continues until the entire object is built up in layers, resulting in a highly precise and detailed final product.

Advantages That Propel MJF to New Heights

One of the key advantages of Multi-Jet Fusion technology lies in its ability to deliver an exceptional surface finish and level of precision that surpasses what can be achieved with FDM prints. The selective application of liquid fusing agents allows for fine control over how each voxel (volumetric pixel) solidifies, resulting in sharp edges, intricate details, and smooth surfaces. This makes MJF particularly well-suited for applications requiring high-quality visual aesthetics or functional parts with tight tolerances.
 
Another notable advantage offered by MJF is its faster printing speed compared to FDM technology. While FDM printers extrude filament layer by layer, MJF printers can simultaneously fuse multiple areas at once using their array of jets.
 
This parallel processing greatly reduces overall print time, making it an attractive choice for time-sensitive projects or high-volume production. Additionally, MJF’s ability to print complex geometries with precision further expands its versatility, opening doors for designing intricate prototypes or functional parts that would be challenging or even impossible to produce using other methods.
FDM prints large models
FDM prints large models
FDM Engineering plastic printing
FDM Engineering plastic printing
MJF Nylon powder printing
MJF Nylon powder printing
MJF small batch parts printing
MJF small batch parts printing

How to cooperate with us?

  1.  Upload your 3D drawings
  2. Our engineer will share quotation and printing suggestions
  3.  Arrange 3D printing service for you

Comparing FDM and MJF Technologies

Aesthetics, Resolution, and Beyond

When comparing the print quality of FDM and MJF technologies, several key differences become apparent. FDM prints tend to exhibit visible layer lines due to the nature of their extrusion process, resulting in a slightly rougher surface finish.
 
On the other hand, MJF prints showcase significantly smoother finishes with virtually imperceptible layer lines, thanks to the precise application of fusing agents and the use of powdered materials. In terms of resolution, while both technologies have the capability to produce intricate details, MJF tends to have an edge over FDM due to its finer voxel control and higher level of precision.
 
This makes it well-suited for applications where intricate features or fine textures are crucial. Given these advantages in surface finish and resolution, it is no surprise that MJF is often preferred for applications requiring high-quality visual aesthetics.
 
Industries such as consumer goods design, architectural modeling, jewelry production, and artistry can greatly benefit from the exceptional print quality offered by Multi-Jet Fusion technology. However, it is worth noting that FDM has its own strengths in simplicity and ruggedness.
 
FDM printers are generally more accessible in terms of cost and user-friendly operation than their MJF counterparts. Moreover, FDM prints tend to be more robust and durable compared to delicate MJF prints.

Conclusion

In a world driven by innovation and creative possibilities offered by 3D printing technology, understanding the differences between Fused Deposition Modeling (FDM) and Multi-Jet Fusion (MJF) becomes crucial when selecting the right technology for a particular application. While FDM offers simplicity, accessibility, and durability, MJF takes the lead in terms of superior surface finish, accuracy, faster printing speed, and the ability to produce complex geometries with high precision. Whether it’s achieving remarkable visual aesthetics or fabricating intricate functional parts, MJF’s capabilities make it an excellent choice.
 
However, FDM still holds a place for those seeking cost-effectiveness and robustness. Ultimately, the decision between FDM and MJF depends on the specific requirements of each project.
 
Both technologies have their unique strengths and applications. Embracing the right technology allows us to unlock new frontiers in creativity and manufacturing capabilities while pushing boundaries for future possibilities in 3D printing.